Law, 01.03.2021 18:20 Vanina2001
The previous Activities have provided you with an economic and
ethical basis for evaluating kidney-transplant policies. Now it is time for you
to be the policy maker. Read the following information and then decide which
policy you support. Be ready to justify your decision. Which policy saves the
most lives? Which conforms most closely to the ethical framework you find most
acceptable?
OPTION 1: THE CURRENT SYSTEM
A national law makes it illegal to sell human organs. Anyone who sells a kidney
faces jail, fines or both. People may donate kidneys, however, and doctors dis-
tribute donated kidneys on the basis of need. Some of the factors they consider
in allocating kidneys are the patient’s age and medical condition, how long the
patient has been on a waiting list and whether the donor is in the local area.
Under this system, there is a shortage of kidneys, and many people are on a
waiting list for years. During this time they receive costly dialysis treatment,
and many people die.
OPTION 2: AN OPEN MARKET
Create an open market in kidneys. People may sell their kidneys on the mar-
ket for the highest price they can get. They may sell and deliver a kidney while
they are still alive, or they may sell for delivery after they die. Brokerage firms
match buyers and sellers. People could even sell kidneys on eBay. Recipients
would pay for the kidney the same way they pay for other medical care: with
their own funds or through insurance, government programs and charity.
OPTION 3: A REGULATED MARKET
Create a market in which anyone may sell a kidney, but only authorized insti-
tutions such as hospitals may legally buy. This option reduces the possibility
of acquiring kidneys through involuntary means such as theft or murder. The
institutions would allocate the kidneys on a basis similar to the way kidneys
are allocated today using age, medical need or time spent on a waiting list.
Recipients would pay for the kidneys with private funds, insurance,
government assistance and charity.
OPTION 4: A COMMUNITARIAN APPROACH
This approach uses nonmarket mechanisms to increase the supply in
several ways.
A marketing campaign would increase people’s awareness of the issue and alter
their preferences for organ donation through moral persuasion. The slogan for a
national television campaign might be “Friends don’t let friends waste the gift
of life.” This is not an appeal to altruism but to people’s sense of moral obliga-
tion and duty.
A more authoritarian policy would legally mandate that when people die, all
their organs will be donated unless they indicate otherwise. People who don’t
want to donate must take the extra step to note this in advance on their driv-
er’s license. Today people must agree in advance for their organs to be donated.
2 -3 paragraphs
Answers: 3
Law, 03.07.2019 15:10
Force protection condition delta means that your base is at which one of the following? (introduction to antiterrorism, page 10) the least increased level of protection the most increased level of protection a medium level of protection
Answers: 2
Law, 05.07.2019 20:30
Asign featuring a red circle and red line crossing over an image
Answers: 1
Law, 07.07.2019 02:10
Limbic system disorders are possible explanations for criminal behavior under_theries? a.classical b.psychoanalytic c.criminal anthropology .d biocriminiology
Answers: 1
Law, 12.07.2019 02:20
1. once you decide that it is safe to move out of traffic, what steps should you follow to ensure safe passage? 2. give some examples where it is unsafe to travel at the speed limit 3. when parking downhill with a curb, what steps would you follow with an automatic transmission? what about manual transmission? 4. what are three things you can do to safely leave a vehicle? ! its due in 3 hours! 100 points to anyone who can at least with one : (
Answers: 2
The previous Activities have provided you with an economic and
ethical basis for evaluating kidney-...
Biology, 28.06.2019 16:00
Arts, 28.06.2019 16:00
Arts, 28.06.2019 16:00
Biology, 28.06.2019 16:00
Mathematics, 28.06.2019 16:00
Geography, 28.06.2019 16:00
English, 28.06.2019 16:00
Mathematics, 28.06.2019 16:00
Spanish, 28.06.2019 16:00
Chemistry, 28.06.2019 16:00
World Languages, 28.06.2019 16:00