Which of the following scenarios would support the argument that inherited traits are as important as parenting style in determining how a child turns out? Carly’s parents have always been affectionate with her and have given her a lot of autonomy. Carly sometimes skips school. Her response is that the class is dumb and she has better things to do with her time.

Rob’s father died when he was small. His mother is often depressed and shows little affection. She does not set a lot of rules. Rob has been making his own meals for years. He decides when to do his homework. Rob gets mostly As and is a peer mentor.

Anita’s mother sets tight rules and punishes Anita when she does not follow them. Anita seldom breaks rules. She is meek and well behaved.

Tim’s parents have a lot of rules but are willing to talk things out. For example, they said that he had to have a B average to play sports. They then realized that some subjects were hard for him and decided that his privileges would be based on his effort; not his grades. Tim is respectful and hardworking and has never been in serious trouble.

Tim
Carly
Rob
Anita