Both "the adventure of the speckled band" and "the boscombe valley mystery" end with sherlock holmes solving the case, yet neither story contains an arrest of the guilty party. in "the adventure of the speckled band," holmes turns back the swamp adder, which leads to the death of dr. roylott. in "the boscombe valley mystery," holmes lets mr. turner live out the rest of his life in freedom. how does the way holmes handles the perpetrators of the crimes affect the way you view holmes? is he entirely admirable? is he somehow "above the law"? is his behavior ethical? why or why not?

The way Holmes handles the perpetrators of the crimes affect how I view Holmes in a significant way: these examples show that, even with all the characteristics that put Holmes one step ahead of most human being, he is somehow still human, human enough to do something that is not considered right for many, but for him it is. It showed me that Holmes has an integrity I never considered before.

For me, it is, as it proves his integrity and also the dedication to his work. He does not want to punish the guilty, instead what really concerns Holmes is the discovery of the truth. In that sense, his mission is admirable.

Yes, it is possible to say that he sees himself as “above the law”. Holmes does not care for trivial human conventions, as he displayed on many occasions throughout his career. He believes that his ability and talent are enough to put him above the law.

It depends on what it is considered ethical. From his point of view, surely it is ethical. From the point of view of the justice system, it is surely not ethical. From a personal perspective, while I do understand his point of view, I do not consider his behavior ethical.

I do consider his behavior ethical because, while he has many talents and abilities, no man should be seen himself as above the law. It takes only one man to consider himself as so to justify every other man to do the same, and so this would led to many men thinking they could do justice on their own. 

the answer is academic paper

and the second should be college professor